Join our upcoming webinar on 1st December - Auto360 and the Golden Record: The journey starts NOW

Register now

Why 43% of aftersales revenue goes elsewhere

Every car that leaves your forecourt creates years of aftersales potential. The opportunity is to make sure more of that future servicing revenue comes back to you and to use every booking, quote and workshop interaction to strengthen customer lifetime value.

New independent research among 2,000 UK car owners, commissioned by CitNOW Group and carried out by Censuswide in June 2026, highlights a clear opportunity for franchised dealers to extend the aftersales relationship beyond the point of sale. Today, 26% of drivers use a franchised dealer as their primary servicing destination, while independent workshops capture 43% of servicing work. National chains, mixed providers and DIY make up the rest, showing exactly where dealers can focus to win back share.

For franchised dealers, this represents a significant and highly addressable growth opportunity to win back servicing revenue, strengthen retention and increase customer lifetime value. In this article, we’ll explore where customers are being lost, what’s driving them to switch, and the practical steps dealers can take to keep them for longer.

The biggest retention opportunity in Aftersales

The research identifies a clear and highly addressable retention opportunity around vehicle age and warranty status. While 45% of drivers with a vehicle still under manufacturer warranty choose a franchised dealer for servicing, this falls to 17% once warranty cover expires.

  • 45% of in-warranty drivers still use a franchised dealer
  • Once that warranty expires, it’s just 17%

Importantly, this is not a lost market, the post-warranty segment represents the single largest opportunity for dealers to grow workshop revenue and customer lifetime value. The data suggests that customers are not rejecting the franchised channel outright; they are reassessing their options based on value, convenience and trust.

Younger drivers are the clearest audience for proactive retention. Nearly half of 18–24 year olds (49%) have switched away from a franchised dealer in the last three years, compared with 19% of over-55s. They are also the most fragmented group, showing little loyalty to any one type of provider, which means they are highly addressable for dealers that make the experience easy, transparent and digitally convenient.

Why customers are defecting

The encouraging news for franchised dealers is that the factors driving customer switching are largely within their control. Customers are not leaving because servicing quality is lacking; they are leaving when expectations around value, convenience and transparency are not being met. Our findings showed the three main reasons for moving away from franchised dealers were:

1. Cost: 42% overall, rising to 58% among over-55s. Price sensitivity intensifies with age, not fades.

2. Convenience and location: 37%, consistent across all age groups.

3. Trust: 31% cited finding a more trusted independent

This finding is particularly important because trust is a competitive advantage that franchised dealers are well positioned to build. Customers increasingly want reassurance that recommendations are appropriate, pricing is fair and work has been completed as promised. The research suggests that providing visible proof of value, rather than simply competing on price, creates a stronger platform for long-term loyalty.

Younger drivers reveal a different pressure point entirely: 40% of 18–24 year olds cited poor appointment availability as their reason for leaving – four times the rate among over-55s. For this generation, it isn’t really about price. It’s about whether they can get an appointment that fits their life, on a channel they’re comfortable using.

Confidence in value declines as vehicles age, creating a significant opportunity for dealers to adapt their proposition to older vehicles. While 72% of drivers feel confident in the value of servicing a car under three years old, this falls to 33% for vehicles over ten years old.

Together, these findings highlight a significant area of potential. Cost concerns can be addressed through upfront pricing and flexible service offers. Convenience can be improved through digital booking and real-time availability. Trust can be strengthened through transparent communication, itemised pricing and evidence of completed work. Each of these leading switching factors represents a clear area of action dealers can take today.

Digital convenience – a powerful competitive advantage

For many customers, the booking experience is now as important as the service itself. The research shows strong demand for a simpler, transparent digital journey, giving dealers a clear opportunity to differentiate without changing their workshop operations.

  • 82% of drivers want to know the price before they book.
  • 41% simply won’t book at all without seeing a price upfront.
  • Encouragingly, 71% are comfortable with an estimated price range, a fixed quote isn’t required, just transparency.

Digital readiness is already there, if dealers want to and can meet it: 66% of customers say they’d book entirely online if the process was simple and clear, and 44% actively want to book and confirm date, time and price instantly, with no call-back needed. Yet telephone still handles 46% of all bookings today, a channel that falls out of favour fast with younger customers, dropping to just 29% among 25–34 year olds, who are already living in an app-and-website world.

The cost of not making the digital journey frictionless is real: 30% of customers who start an online booking abandon it before completion, a figure that rises to 48% among under-25s. The number one reason given is simple: they couldn’t find a suitable appointment time. For dealers without live, integrated diary availability, this is a direct handover of business to a competitor who does.

Where change needs to happen

The research points to six clear areas where franchised dealers can win back share, none of which require reinventing the business, just closing gaps that customers are telling us exist today.

Transparency. Show a live price, or a credible estimated range, before any personal details are requested. With 82% demanding this and 71% happy with an estimate rather than a fixed figure, this is the lowest-friction, highest-impact change available.

Flexibility. Adopt a hybrid pricing model: an inspection-based estimate for complex work, paired with fixed pricing for routine jobs like MOTs and interim services. This satisfies the majority without requiring a fixed quote for every job type.

Availability. Integrate the workshop diary so all genuine appointment slots are visible and bookable online. This is the single fix most likely to arrest the exodus of younger, digitally-native customers for whom availability, not price, is the top reason for leaving.

Seamlessness. Build a true self-service booking flow with date, time and price confirmed instantly, not an enquiry form followed by a call-back. Nearly half of customers want this today; the phone-based default is actively working against dealer retention.

Simplicity. Cut the booking journey down to the fewest possible steps and fix the friction points – registration look-up failures, over-long forms, missing pricing that are driving abandonment, particularly among the under-25 segment where nearly half give up mid-booking.

Loyalty. Treat retention of the younger, digital-first customer as a strategic priority, not an afterthought. Itemised quotes, photo and video evidence of work carried out, and proactive communication all build the trust that keeps a customer coming back once their warranty expires, the exact moment competitors are best placed to take them.

The opportunity ahead

The research paints an encouraging picture for franchised dealers. Customers continue to value expertise, manufacturer backing and trusted service, yet many are being pushed toward alternative providers by barriers that can be removed.

Drivers outside warranty are the largest risk of defection and can be retained through better price transparency, whilst the younger generations are actively seeking more convenient digital experiences. None of these expectations require a fundamental change in business model. Franchised workshops that focus on transparency, availability, convenience and trust can extend customer relationships well beyond the warranty period, increase workshop utilisation and capture a greater share of the aftersales market. The data does not suggest a lack of demand for franchised servicing. It highlights where customers experience friction and, importantly, where dealers have the greatest opportunity to act.

Learn how CitNOW is helping dealerships in the UK to maximise customer retention while optimising workshop performance.

— 

Source: CitNOW Group Aftersales Consumer Research, based on an independent survey of 2,000 UK car owners conducted by Censuswide, June 2026.